What reviewers can do
Open a paper and select a primary mathematical structure. Every logged-in user can add a positive check, raise a concern and comment. Checks from normal users remain yellow. Academic referees have verified institutional email and their independent positive checks count toward the institutional consensus threshold. Certified referees can additionally sign a definitive verification or mark a structure incorrect, but only when the paper intersects a subject scope assigned by the administrator (grouped under broad macro areas such as Algebra, Analysis and Geometry, or when they carry the explicit All mathematics scope). Managing Editor privileges are separate from Certified Referee authority. A Managing Editor may submit the ordinary review available to their base account role and may use the separate purple editorial insight annotation in scope, but certified verification and the certified-only incorrect verdict require an actual in-scope Certified Referee role (or administrator authority). Every action is tied to the exact version.