Skip to main content
PF:2026.000018 · Combinatorics

The cofinite regularity spectrum of $F$-irregular graphs

Uploaded by: Zhanhe Zhang · version 1 · 2026-10-11 04:08:55
Generated by:
  1. Zhanhe Zhang · Central University of Finance and Economics
License: ProofForum perpetual non-exclusive distribution license 1.0 · Copyright is retained; ProofForum receives the rights needed to host, preserve and distribute this version.
Full-paper AI · OpenAI GPT 6 · High reasoning effort · passedFull-paper AI · OpenAI GPT-6 · Extended / deep reasoning · error
Evidence-backed credit

Substantive mathematical contributions

Show proposals

Concrete proposals are tied to an immutable base version. When the paper owner confirms a contribution, it can be linked to the later manuscript version that incorporated it, was revised because of it, or resolved the issue independently. If the owner has not decided within 90 days, an administrator or a Managing Editor of the paper's subject area can take an editorial decision. Proposals by co-authors are recorded but give no contribution credit.

Indexed mathematical statement

Lemma 6.4: Four-cycle principal term

PF:2026.000018/v1/LEM-6.4

Let $F$ be a connected triangle-free graph of order $h$ containing a four-cycle. Let $R$ be an $\omega$-regular auxiliary graph constructed as in \hyperref[sec:wiring]{Section reference}, with positive seed degrees and with bounded proper-level generator counts as in Theorem 5.2. Suppose $\tau_R$ is constant. For distinct roots $v,w$, put $u=q_{\istar}$ and $\eps=\omega/N$. Then a_F\Delta d_F^{\overline R} =8c_4(F)N^{h-4}\Delta c_4^R +O_F\bigl((\eps+N^{-1})N^{h-4}u^3\bigr).

Open the parent paper · This indexed statement is a discovery surface and does not itself imply human verification.

Loading PDF...
Dependency map

Mathematical dependencies

Click a node to select the same theorem, lemma or proposition in the review sidebar. The sidebar stays available while you inspect the graph. Solid arrows are explicit LaTeX references; dashed arrows are legacy structural suggestions and are never treated as proof evidence.

Paper history

Versions

Every version is immutable. Open an earlier version or compare revisions here without leaving the paper reader layout.

Bibliography

References

ProofForum parses references embedded in the uploaded LaTeX. Internal PF IDs are linked and colored by the current human-review state of the cited paper: green = fully certified tracked structures, yellow = partial review/concern, red = incorrect point reported, grey = no human verification or unresolved internal ID. arXiv and Hexagon identifiers cited with a prefix or link are matched to ProofForum verification records: a state is shown only for the exact cited version; a citation without a version is marked as a matching work.

  1. G. Chartrand, K. S. Holbert, O. R. Oellermann and H. C. Swart, $F$-degrees in graphs, Ars Combin. 24 (1987), 133--148.
    LaTeX source\bibitem{CHOS1987} G. Chartrand, K. S. Holbert, O. R. Oellermann and H. C. Swart, $F$-degrees in graphs, Ars Combin. 24 (1987), 133--148.
    External reference
  2. G. Chartrand, P. Erd\Hos and O. R. Oellermann, How to define an irregular graph, College Math. J. 19 (1988), 36--42. https://doi.org/10.1080/07468342.1988.11973088.
    LaTeX source\bibitem{CEO1988} G. Chartrand, P. Erd\H{o}s and O. R. Oellermann, How to define an irregular graph, College Math. J. 19 (1988), 36--42. \url{https://doi.org/10.1080/07468342.1988.11973088}.
    External reference
  3. J. A. Schreib, A construction of $F$-irregular graphs, arXiv:2609.07745 (2026).
    LaTeX source\bibitem{Schreib2026} J. A. Schreib, A construction of $F$-irregular graphs, arXiv:2609.07745 (2026).
    External reference
  4. T. Dovzhenok and A. Filuta, A complete proof of the strong conjecture about $F$-irregular graphs, arXiv:2609.19245 (2026).
    LaTeX source\bibitem{DF2026} T. Dovzhenok and A. Filuta, A complete proof of the strong conjecture about $F$-irregular graphs, arXiv:2609.19245 (2026).
    External reference
  5. Z. Berikkyzy, B. Bjorkman, H. Smith Blake, S. Jahanbekam, L. Keough, K. Moss, D. Rorabaugh and S. Shan, Triangle-degree and triangle-distinct graphs, Discrete Math. 347(1) (2024), Article 113695. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.disc.2023.113695.
    LaTeX source\bibitem{Berikkyzy2024} Z. Berikkyzy, B. Bjorkman, H. Smith Blake, S. Jahanbekam, L. Keough, K. Moss, D. Rorabaugh and S. Shan, Triangle-degree and triangle-distinct graphs, Discrete Math. 347(1) (2024), Article 113695. \url{https://doi.org/10.1016/j.disc.2023.113695}.
    External reference
  6. D. Stevanovi\'c, M. Ghebleh, G. Caporossi, A. Vijayakumar and S. Stevanovi\'c, On regular triangle-distinct graphs, Comput. Appl. Math. 43(6) (2024), Article 336. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40314-024-02854-9.
    LaTeX source\bibitem{Stevanovic2024} D. Stevanovi\'c, M. Ghebleh, G. Caporossi, A. Vijayakumar and S. Stevanovi\'c, On regular triangle-distinct graphs, Comput. Appl. Math. 43(6) (2024), Article 336. \url{https://doi.org/10.1007/s40314-024-02854-9}.
    External reference
  7. A. Hak, S. Kozerenko and A. Serdiuk, Regular $K_3$-irregular graphs, arXiv:2507.18776v2 (2026).
    LaTeX source\bibitem{Hak2025} A. Hak, S. Kozerenko and A. Serdiuk, Regular $K_3$-irregular graphs, arXiv:2507.18776v2 (2026).
    External reference
  8. Z. Zhang, Regular $K_3$-irregular graphs of every regularity at least nine, arXiv:2610.08478 (2026).
    LaTeX source\bibitem{ZhangK3} Z. Zhang, Regular $K_3$-irregular graphs of every regularity at least nine, arXiv:2610.08478 (2026).
    External reference
  9. A. Hak, S. Kozerenko and A. Serdiuk, There is no $8$-regular $K_3$-irregular graph, arXiv:2609.37978 (2026).
    LaTeX source\bibitem{HakNo8} A. Hak, S. Kozerenko and A. Serdiuk, There is no $8$-regular $K_3$-irregular graph, arXiv:2609.37978 (2026).
    External reference
  10. A. Draganova, Results on $F$-continuous graphs, Czechoslovak Math. J. 59(1) (2009), 51--60. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10587-009-0004-8.
    LaTeX source\bibitem{Draganova2009} A. Draganova, Results on $F$-continuous graphs, Czechoslovak Math. J. 59(1) (2009), 51--60. \url{https://doi.org/10.1007/s10587-009-0004-8}.
    External reference
Incoming citations

Cited by

Published ProofForum papers that cite this paper or an exact persistent object in this immutable version.

No published ProofForum paper currently cites this paper or one of this version’s indexed objects.
This is an internal ProofForum citation index, not a claim about citations across the whole scholarly web.
Formal verification

Lean / Palomar

Machine-checked Lean evidence is linked through immutable Palomar registry records. ProofForum separately tracks statement-to-declaration correspondence and independent human alignment review.

No Palomar formalization is linked to this paper version.
Machine-readable theorem index · 19 statements

Public text index for scholarly discovery. It mirrors theorem, lemma, proposition and related statements from this immutable version and does not imply human verification.

  1. PF:2026.000018/v1/THM-1.1

    Let $F$ be a finite, simple, connected graph with at least three vertices. If $F$ is a star, then $\Spec(F)=\varnothing$. Otherwise there exists an integer $r_F$ such that for \emph{every} integer $r\ge r_F$ there is a finite simple connected $r$-regular $F$-irregular graph $G_r$ of diameter exactly two. Moreover, the hosts can be chosen so that $|V(G_r)|/r\to1$ as $r\to\infty$.

  2. PF:2026.000018/v1/COR-1.2

    A finite connected graph $F$ of order at least three admits a connected regular $F$-irregular host if and only if $F$ is not a star. In the non-star case there are infinitely many such hosts of odd regularity and infinitely many of even regularity, each of diameter two.

  3. PF:2026.000018/v1/LEM-2.1

    There exist graphs satisfying the following properties. \item Two complementary $125$-vertex $62$-regular graphs $A,B$ whose combined $250$ rooted triangle counts are pairwise distinct, with total span $932$. \item The $31250$-vertex $7812$-regular graph H_0=A[A]\ \dot\cup\ B[B] has $31250$ pairwise distinct rooted triangle counts, with total span at most $14\,563\,432$. \item Two $1250$-vertex $310$-regular bipartite graphs $U,V$ with disjoint edge sets under a common vertex labeling. Their $2500$ rooted four-cycle counts are pairwise distinct and have total span $834\,684$.

  4. PF:2026.000018/v1/LEM-4.1

    With $R$ as in (equation reference), all new terms in $\diag(A_R^3-A_{R_0}^3)$ are constant across the vertices. In particular, \Delta\tau_R=\Delta\tau_{R_0} for every two roots.

  5. PF:2026.000018/v1/LEM-4.2

    Take $k$ positions from the two $1250$-vertex seeds $U,V$ of Lemma 2.1, with $\ell\le k$, using color $e_i$ at position $i<\ell$ and fixed color $0$ thereafter. Use any collection of distinct connection generators with a fixed bounded count at each proper level. Then $\tau_R$ is constant, and for every pair of roots \Delta c_4^R=\Delta c_4^{R_0},\qquad |\Delta c_4^R|\ge\left(1-\frac{834\,684}{1250^3-1}\right)u^3.

  6. PF:2026.000018/v1/LEM-5.1

    Let $R$ be an auxiliary graph constructed in \hyperref[sec:wiring]{Section reference}. Fix roots $v=(e,x)$ and $w=(f,y)$, and let $\istar$ be their highest unequal absolute coordinate. Partition $V(R)$ by the word-block label and the letters strictly above $\istar$; every block has size $L_*=q_{\istar+1}$. There is a vertex permutation $\varphi$ with $\varphi(v)=w$ such that the relabeled adjacency matrix \[ A'_R(z,z')=A_R(\varphi(z),\varphi(z')) \] has the same blockwise average $\mathcal U$ as $A_R$. Write $K=A_R-\mathcal U$ and $K'=A'_R-\mathcal U$, and put \[ \omega_*=D_{\istar+1}+\sum_{s:a_s\le\istar}q_{a_s}. \] Then every block of $K$ and $K'$ has zero row and column sums, \[ 0\le\mathcal U(z,z')\le1,\…

  7. PF:2026.000018/v1/THM-5.2

    Fix regular seed alphabets with orders $2\le n_i\le n_{\max}$ and degrees independent of color at each position. Suppose each proper connection level $a<P$ carries at most $M_*$ generators; the number at level $P$ is unrestricted. Let $v,w$ be roots of an auxiliary graph $R$ from \hyperref[sec:wiring]{Section reference}, with highest unequal coordinate $\istar$, and set $u=q_{\istar}$. For any fixed connected rooted graph $(H,a)$ of order $h_H$: \item if $H$ is a tree, $\Hom_v(H,a;R)=\Hom_w(H,a;R)$; \item if $H$ contains a cycle, then |\Delta\Hom(H,a;R)| \le C_{H,M_*}\omega^{h_H-g(H)}u^{g(H)-1}. The constant may depend on the fixed alphabets, $H$ and $M_*$, but not on $P,\ell$, the selected generators or the…

  8. PF:2026.000018/v1/LEM-6.1

    If $G=\overline R$ has order $N\ge2h$, where $h=|V(F)|$, then for any two roots in $G$, a_F\Delta d_F^G =\sum_{\varnothing\ne E'\subseteq E(F)}(-1)^{|E'|} (N-s-1)_{h-s}\,\Delta I_J, where $(x)_m=x(x-1)\cdots(x-m+1)$ for $m\ge1$ and $(x)_0=1$.

  9. PF:2026.000018/v1/LEM-6.2

    Fix $F$ and two roots at suffix scale $u$. Let a quotient of an edge support $J$ have $m$ vertices, $c$ nontrivial connected components and identification defect $d=s-m$. Let $H$ be the quotient component containing the distinguished root. If $H$ has a cycle, choose an integer $q$ with $3\le q\le g(H)$. The contribution of this rooted quotient to (equation reference) is bounded by C_FN^{h-q-d}\left(\frac\omega N\right)^{m-c-q+1}u^{q-1}, \qquad m-c-q+1\ge0. A quotient with the root in a tree component makes no contribution to the root difference.

  10. PF:2026.000018/v1/LEM-6.3

    Let $F$ be connected and $h=|V(F)|$. \item If $F$ contains a triangle, the only root-dependent zero-loss type at scale $N^{h-3}u^2$ is an uncontracted triangle support. Summing over these supports gives coefficient $-6c_3(F)$ multiplying $\Delta\tau_R$. \item If $F$ is triangle-free and contains a $P_4$, the only root-dependent zero-loss type among non-discrete quotients at scale $N^{h-4}u^2$ identifies the endpoints of a $P_4$. Its summed coefficient is $8p_4(F)$ multiplying $\Delta\tau_R$. \item If $F$ has finite girth $g\ge5$, the only zero-loss type among discrete cyclic quotients at scale $N^{h-g}u^{g-1}$ is a single $C_g$ support. Their sum has coefficient $(-1)^ggc_g(F)$ multiplying $\Delta z_g$. In (…

  11. PF:2026.000018/v1/LEM-6.4

    Let $F$ be a connected triangle-free graph of order $h$ containing a four-cycle. Let $R$ be an $\omega$-regular auxiliary graph constructed as in \hyperref[sec:wiring]{Section reference}, with positive seed degrees and with bounded proper-level generator counts as in Theorem 5.2. Suppose $\tau_R$ is constant. For distinct roots $v,w$, put $u=q_{\istar}$ and $\eps=\omega/N$. Then a_F\Delta d_F^{\overline R} =8c_4(F)N^{h-4}\Delta c_4^R +O_F\bigl((\eps+N^{-1})N^{h-4}u^3\bigr).

  12. PF:2026.000018/v1/THM-7.1

    Let $R$ be an auxiliary graph constructed in \hyperref[sec:wiring]{Section reference}, and let $D_i$ be the suffix degree in Eq. (equation reference). Define the matrix $\mathcal B_i$ on $\Gamma\times[n_i]$ by \mathcal B_i=D_iI+q_i\diag_{e\in\Gamma}(A_{S_{i,\chi_i(e)}}) +\sum_{s:a_s\le i}q_{a_s}(T_s\otimes I_{n_i}). For every positive integer $t$ and every two roots $(e,x),(f,y)$ of $R$, \Delta z_t^R =\sum_{i=0}^{P-1}\frac1{q_i} \bigl[(\mathcal B_i^t)_{(e,x_i),(e,x_i)}-(\mathcal B_i^t)_{(f,y_i),(f,y_i)}\bigr]. In particular, top-level generators do not affect these differences.

  13. PF:2026.000018/v1/LEM-7.2

    For each absolute position $i$ and each $t\ge0$, the value $(\mathcal B_i^t)_{(e,x_i),(e,x_i)}$ depends on $e$ only through $\chi_i(e)$. Consequently, all positions above the highest unequal letter cancel exactly in Eq. (equation reference).

  14. PF:2026.000018/v1/LEM-7.3

    Fix $h_0\ge1$ and let $M=2^{h_0}-1$. For $k\ge1$, put $d=h_0\lceil\log_2(k+1)/h_0\rceil$. Whenever $p\ge2d+1$, there are $k$ different $h_0$-dimensional binary subspaces of $\FF_2^p$, all contained in the bit-$0$ zero hyperplane, and any two meeting only in zero.

  15. PF:2026.000018/v1/LEM-7.4

    Fix an integer $g\ge5$. For the mixed-radix construction and generator allocation specified above, there exist constants $M=2^{h_0}-1$, $p_0$, $\lambda_g^->0$ and $\lambda_g^+<\infty$, independent of $r,p,k,\ell$, such that, whenever $p\ge p_0$ and $\istar=p+j$ with $j\ge p$, setting $u=q_{\istar}$ and $\sigma=\operatorname{sgn}(\delta_{\istar})$ gives \lambda_g^-|\delta_{\istar}| \le \sigma\frac{\Delta z_g^R}{u^{g-1}} \le\lambda_g^+|\delta_{\istar}|. The constants can be chosen so that 4\frac{1+\eta}{1-\eta}\frac{\lambda_g^+}{\lambda_g^-} <125^{g-3}.

  16. PF:2026.000018/v1/LEM-8.1

    Let $\alpha\notin\mathbb Q$ and $\theta>0$. There is an integer $T_0(\alpha,\theta)$ such that, for every $T\ge T_0$, every integer $a$, and every phase $\beta$, the set \[ \{\,\beta+(a+t)\alpha\pmod1:0\le t<T\,\} \] has maximum circular gap $d_T<\theta$. Thus $d_T\to0$ uniformly over $a$ and $\beta$; also $d_T\ge1/T$.

  17. PF:2026.000018/v1/LEM-8.2

    Fix $n=125$, $b=31250$, integers $g\ge5$ and $h_0\ge1$, $M=2^{h_0}-1$, a constant $\gamma>0$, and a nonempty open arc $I$ on the circle $\RR/((g-3)\log n)\mathbb Z$. For every sufficiently large integer $r$ there are integers $p,k,\ell\ge1$ and a family of distinct generators in (equation reference) such that \item $N=2^\ell b^pn^k$ and $r=N-1-\omega$ hold exactly; \item $p<\ell<k$, $\omega/N\to0$, and for $Q=b^pn^k$ the residual wiring degree $t=\omega-D$ satisfies $t/Q\to\infty$, uniformly in the admissible $p$ window; \item every amplified upper level uses the $M$ nonzero vectors from its designated complete subspace, with disjoint sets across levels, and at most $124$ additional digit generators. All pro…

  18. PF:2026.000018/v1/LEM-8.3

    Fix a regular seed alphabet of order $m\ge3$ and degree $d$, where $m$ is not a power of two and $1\le d<m$. For every sufficiently large integer $r$, the layered construction admits parameters $k>\ell\ge1$ and distinct proper- and top-level generators such that \[ Q=m^k,\qquad D=d\frac{Q-1}{m-1},\qquad N=2^\ell Q,\qquad r=N-1-D-t, \] where $t\ge0$, $t/Q\to\infty$ and $t/N\to0$ as $r\to\infty$. At each proper level at most $m-1$ generators are used.

  19. PF:2026.000018/v1/LEM-14.1

    Let $A,B$ be adjacency matrices of complementary $d$-regular graphs on $n=2d+1$ vertices, and let $Z$ be any $q\times q$ zero--one matrix. Put $E=A-B$ and \[ \mathsf M=J_q\otimes B+Z\otimes E,\qquad P_0=qJ_q,\quad P_1=ZJ_q+J_qZ^T,\quad P_2=ZZ^T. \] For $j=0,\ldots,4$, let $a_j(i)$ be the $i$th diagonal entry of the corresponding matrix in \[ P_0^2,\quad P_0P_1+P_1P_0,\quad P_1^2+P_0P_2+P_2P_0,\\ P_1P_2+P_2P_1,\quad P_2^2. \] In the bipartite graph with incidence matrix $\mathsf M$, the rooted four-cycle count at the left vertex $(i,x)$ is c_4(i,x)=\frac12\left(\sum_{j=0}^4 a_j(i)(B^{4-j}E^j)_{xx} -2(qd)^2+qd\right). Right-vertex counts are obtained by replacing $Z$ with $Z^T$. For the complementary block sub…